‘Shogun’ and ‘Tokyo Vice’ successes expose a big gap in streaming services — and it’s time to fix it (2024)

‘Shogun’ and ‘Tokyo Vice’ successes expose a big gap in streaming services — and it’s time to fix it (1)

Japan — it’s a tantalizing place fueled by the strange curiosities of anime, otherworldly delicatessens, and the constant bustle of work, work, work. The late Anthony Bourdain may have said it best in the opening monologue of one “Parts Unknown” episode aptly set in Tokyo, Japan:

“For those with restless, curious minds, fascinated by layer upon layer of things, flavors, tastes and customs which we will never fully be able to understand, Tokyo is deliciously unknowable.”

Drawing this unknowing out in expert fashion are two of the biggest shows on TV right now, Hulu’s “Shogun” and Max's “Tokyo Vice.” Both are vastly different portrayals, opposite sides of the same coin that is Japan, showcasing a rich and beautiful history with a pureness that’s ripe for the ever-wary travelers out there.

On one side is the neon-soaked crime thriller of “Tokyo Vice,” which follows in the wake of its namesake taking up “Miami Vice” showrunner Michael Mann as producer, dropping viewers into the Yakuza-ruled world of Tokyo. On the other is the Bushido-based period piece of “Shogun” that follows Lord Yoshii Toranaga in a hard-fought quest to gain control of Japan.

Both, though veering slightly from reality, take inspiration from true historical events — particularly power struggles that wracked Japan in the 1990s and 1600s, respectively. Their immediate success, with “Tokyo Vice” now halfway through its second season and “Shogun” sealing itself into the annals of history with a 9.2 rating on IMDB, proves Japan is a setting totally worth its enigmatic thunder — and more like them should follow suit.

Where criminality and honor converge

“Tokyo Vice” on Max sports the backdrop of 1990s Japan starring Ansel Elgort as Jake Adelstein, an up-and-coming news reporter at the fictional Meicho Shimbun. Elgort is joined by the Japanese native Ken Watanabe, who plays a respected detective in the organized crime division of Tokyo’s Metropolitan Police Department, named Hiroto Katagiri.

Katagiri and Adelstein join forces in an attempt to bring to light the Yakuza’s ever-growing foothold over Tokyo, which is largely being led by the ruthless Shinzo Tozawa. Though most of the story is loosely based on real events, the character names (aside from Adelstein himself) have been altered and much of the narrative has been dramatized for added effect.

Despite this, “Tokyo Vice” still does a great job of showcasing each and every angle of 1990s Japan — from the stringent inner workings of a Japanese newspaper to the criminal underpinnings of the Yakuza upheld by a deeply honorable code. It’s an expert look back in time, pulling viewers into the real power struggles that saw varied Yakuza organizations fighting for control over Tokyo.

The story is inspired by Jake Adelstein's memoir, "Tokyo Vice: An American Reporter on the Police Beat in Japan," wherein he details his time in the country as a reporter at one of its most respected newspapers — a feat few (if any) foreigners have achieved since. It's an expert look into Japan's tight-knit culture, one that is also expressed plainly through the crime syndicates and their interwoven respect.

‘Shogun’ and ‘Tokyo Vice’ successes expose a big gap in streaming services — and it’s time to fix it (2)

This painting of the Yakuza proves to be the shining feat of "Tokyo Vice." Viewers are drawn into this underworld by the aspiring enforcer named Sato of the Chihara-Kai clan, which is led by the honorable Hitoshi Ishida. Without getting too much into spoiler territory, the latest episode of "Tokyo Vice" really nails down this relationship between Sato and his Oyabun and proves just how much this crime thriller ranks among the best shows on Max.

It will be extremely exciting to see where the story goes next as the Tokyo Metropolitan Police force — aided by Adelstein — seek to bring an immediate end to these criminal organizations and their deadly infighting. Despite it's focus on this nature of criminality, I feel "Tokyo Vice" still gives Japan that special limelight and presents its culture in such fascinating ways that more shows need to emulate.

The way of the sword

Spanning from around the year 1185 to 1868, Japan was embroiled in a military dictatorship spurned by consistent infighting and political malfeasance. This era would find its lasting memory and cultural touchstone when the battle of Sekigahara was won by the great Tokugawa Ieyasu — for which Hulu’s “Shogun” takes up most of its inspiration and Hiroyuki Sanada’s Lord Yoshii Toranaga himself is loosely based upon.

The real Lord Ieyasu would later devise the so-called Bakufu, which translates to “tent government,” pertaining to an official system that formalized social governance and administration following several eras fueled by constant war. As the country’s newly-seated Shogun — hence the show’s title — Lord Ieyasu would be the one to inevitably lead Japan into a period of nearly 300 years of peace.

“Shogun” isn’t exactly a mirror to these real-world events, but presents them in a way that is captivating and far easier to follow for Western audiences. Think of Hulu’s “Shogun” as a pseudo “Game of Thrones” dramatization of that history, taking up several bits of inspiration presented in Giles Milton’s “Samurai William: The Englishman Who Opened Japan.”

"Shogun" has received immediate acclaim and recognition not just as one of the best shows on Hulu — but potentially among the best shows period. It's proving to be quite the experience to follow for those who aren't even fascinated by Japanese culture — and for those who are, they get to bask in this incredible time period, one that gives the show its meaningful backbone.

It's also quite telling to me that two of the most popular shows set in Japan right now are led by the most well-known Japanese stars of our time, those being "Shogun's" Hiroyuki Sanada and "Tokyo Vice's" Ken Watanabe — both of whom made everlasting appearances in the 2003 hit "The Last Samurai."

With such powerful shows like these taking center stage and shining the spotlight on Japan, more should follow in their footsteps. This beautiful country is full of incredible, interesting histories to explore, places to lose oneself in, and imagination writ large. Japan's almost like an escape into a fantasy plain, a strip of land that is host to fascinations and culture that will leave even the most indifferent of adventurers breathless.

Through all of the real-world strife as shown in such series as "Tokyo Vice," "Shogun" and well beyond, the country remains emphatically all its own and seeks to keep tradition at the forefront of its culture. More shows like these should take up the lessons presented in them, ensuring Japan's rich culture stays as true to itself on-screen as it is in the annals of history.

More from Tom's Guide

  • ‘Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End’ taught me how to respect time — and yet I can’t stop watching
  • How to watch 'Celebrity Big Brother' 2024 online and for free
  • Best Netflix anime shows and movies in February 2024

Get the BEST of Tom’s Guide daily right in your inbox: Sign up now!

Upgrade your life with the Tom’s Guide newsletter. Subscribe now for a daily dose of the biggest tech news, lifestyle hacks and hottest deals. Elevate your everyday with our curated analysis and be the first to know about cutting-edge gadgets.

‘Shogun’ and ‘Tokyo Vice’ successes expose a big gap in streaming services — and it’s time to fix it (4)

Ryan Epps

Staff Writer

Ryan Epps is a Staff Writer under the TV/AV section at Tom's Guide focusing on TVs and projectors. When not researching PHOLEDs and writing about the next major innovation in the projector space, he's consuming random anime from the 90's, playing Dark Souls 3 again, or reading yet another Haruki Murakami novel.

More about streaming

'The Bear' season 4 gets greenlight ahead of season 3 premiere'Doctor Strange' character teased for MCU return — here's where they could appear


7 top new movies to stream this week on Netflix, Prime Video, Hulu and more (March 19-March 25)
See more latest►

2 CommentsComment from the forums

  • VicTheCat

    I don't agree that the success of these streaming shows is because of the rich Japanese heritage.

    Yes Japanese heritage and history has an expensive rich and colorful background.

    But good story telling that isn't woke or filled with ideology or just plain crap will fix the streaming services profitable and membership problems.

    The Cat


  • timwhite76

    Japan is an interesting setting, but it's incidental. The shows are popular because they're actually well done. Well, at least Shogun is, I've never watched the other one. The rational behind the idea that it's because of the setting that makes it good ia the very reason why everything else falls between mediocre and terrible. The studios thought that the settings were all that mattered: the MCU, Star Wars, LOTR, etc. That clearly isn't the case.


Most Popular
Dragon Ball Z: Kakarot is helping me mourn the loss of Akira Toriyama

By Tony Polanco

I used the Apple Vision Pro for 1 month — here's the truth

By Mark Spoonauer

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it

By Tony Polanco

I didn’t get the hype around foldable phones, but the Galaxy Z Fold 5 changed my mind — here's why

By Josh Render

7 best Hulu miniseries to binge-watch this weekend

By Malcolm McMillan

I finally got a PlayStation Portal — don’t make the same mistake I did

By Dave Meikleham

Google DeepMind trains AI to play No Man's Sky and other video games — meet your new copilot

By Ryan Morrison

Amazon Prime Video’s new ads are such a disaster I might cancel

By Rory Mellon

TikTok faces ban — here's 3 ways it can survive

By Ryan Morrison

The best show you're not watching is back on Netflix

By Josh Bell

I've been overpaying for my Tidal music subscription via Apple — don't make this mistake

By Lee Dunkley

‘Shogun’ and ‘Tokyo Vice’ successes expose a big gap in streaming services — and it’s time to fix it (2024)


Was Tokyo Vice a success? ›

While Max has yet to officially announce Tokyo Vice Season 3, the show's popularity suggests a strong possibility. Season 2's success, currently ranked No 31 in overall popularity with a 10.91 engagement score, makes a third season likely.

What is the ending of Tokyo Vice explained? ›

Later, in the season's final scene and some time after Tozawa's death, Jake shows Katagiri his story, with the headline “Deceased Yakuza Boss Had Secret Deal with FBI.” Katagiri working with Sato to end Tozawa's reign presumably isn't part of that story, and won't ever be public knowledge.

Is Shōgun a success? ›

Stateside, Shōgun is also now the most-streamed TV premiere for an FX-developed show. The Feudal Japan-set series has climbed above The Bear season 2, which previously held top spot. Overseas, Shōgun moved past The Kardashians season 1 to take the number one spot in the General Entertainment series category, too.

What channel is Shōgun streaming on? ›

You can stream it on Hulu in the US at 12 a.m. ET, and at 10 p.m. ET on FX's linear cable network on those dates. International viewers can watch on Disney Plus via the Star hub. Because Shōgun is a limited series, a second season is not planned.

Did actor learn Japanese for Tokyo Vice? ›

Ansel Elgort on How 'Tokyo Vice' Just Circled Around to the Start of the Series. "I kind of knew the story but I hadn't lived those events yet," says Elgort, who is now fluent in Japanese, of the March 21 episode filling in the blanks set up in the Michael Mann-directed pilot.

How popular is Tokyo Vice in Japan? ›

The show has been very well received in Japan. For me, one of the main goals of doing the show was to present Japan in an authentic way, so it makes me especially proud that I have had compliments from many of our Japanese viewers.

Who is the white girl in Tokyo Vice? ›

Rachel Keller as Samantha Porter, an American expatriate living in Tokyo and former Mormon who makes her living as a hostess in the Onyx Club of the Kabukicho district, and later starts her own club. Her clients vary from salarymen to high-end clients and yakuza.

How factual is Tokyo Vice? ›

Although Tokyo Vice is loosely inspired by Adelstein's time covering the crime beat in Tokyo, showrunner J.T. Rogers has stated that the series is not a completely accurate autobiographical account.

Is Tokyo Vice only 3 episodes? ›

Tokyo Vice season 2 consists of 10 episodes, two more than the previous season. Tokyo Vice season 3 has not been announced. The Tokyo Vice season 2 finale is set to premiere soon. The final episode of Tokyo Vice season 2 was written by Tony-winning playwright and showrunner J.T.

What do Japanese think of shogun series? ›

Though the $25 million production delivered ratings and awards wins stateside, for those from Japan, the show was criticized for its brutality yet praised for building a cultural bridge between the two countries. “Shōgun” was a series that revolutionized television, both due to its scale and its international focus.

Is shogun FX popular in Japan? ›

Now, a new 10-episode series also titled “Shogun” and streaming on Disney+ in Japan, has become a massive hit, recording 9 million views worldwide in the first six days since its release on Feb.

Why is shogun so highly rated? ›

Perhaps the greatest success of “Shogun” is in its characters. Hiroyuki Sanada plays the imposing Lord Toranaga with such regality and honor that you can perfectly understand and respect the character's honor while the writing demonstrates the aspects of his cunning and his potential for brutality.

Will Shōgun be on Disney Plus? ›

The ten-episode limited series premiered its first two episodes on February 27. Each new episode is available to stream on both Hulu and Disney+ at 12:01 A.M. ET on its respective release date, before its FX premiere at 10:00 P.M.

Will Shōgun be on FX channel? ›

FX's Shōgun Is 10 Episodes of Pure Epic Television

This based-on-a-true-story power struggle has already been compared to Game of Thrones.

Why isn t Shōgun on Disney Plus? ›

To watch Shogun, you'll need to change the content rating under parental controls.

Will there be a Tokyo Vice 2? ›

Tokyo Vice returns with a more exacting outing, one willing to let characters find new twists on old rules, rejigger their thinking, and approach the world from a new perspective. This is a show preparing an audience for the long haul. Content collapsed.

Is season 2 of Tokyo Vice the last season? ›

That's the end of this two-season story, but is it the end of Tokyo Vice? It doesn't have to be. “I ended the season so that we could, if we were done, satisfy the audience and ourselves,” Rogers says. “But I very much have a very clear idea for season 3, and we would love to do it, so we will find out.”

How many episodes are there in season 2 of Tokyo Vice? ›

Tokyo Vice season 2 consists of 10 episodes, two more than the previous season. Tokyo Vice season 3 has not been announced. The Tokyo Vice season 2 finale is set to premiere soon. The final episode of Tokyo Vice season 2 was written by Tony-winning playwright and showrunner J.T.


Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Geoffrey Lueilwitz

Last Updated:

Views: 6007

Rating: 5 / 5 (60 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Geoffrey Lueilwitz

Birthday: 1997-03-23

Address: 74183 Thomas Course, Port Micheal, OK 55446-1529

Phone: +13408645881558

Job: Global Representative

Hobby: Sailing, Vehicle restoration, Rowing, Ghost hunting, Scrapbooking, Rugby, Board sports

Introduction: My name is Geoffrey Lueilwitz, I am a zealous, encouraging, sparkling, enchanting, graceful, faithful, nice person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.